Showing posts with label Retirement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Retirement. Show all posts

Saturday, July 6, 2013

Retirement savings: Couple, 70, wonders how to make them last

Retirement savings: Couple, 70, wonders how to make them last


Monday Makeover looks at a 70-year-old couple wondering how much they can safely spend each year without depleting their savings.


Carl and Donna are ready for some fun. So, at age 70, they are planning a $9,000 trip.
This is a luxury they can certainly afford. They have more pension income than their $29,000 of basic living expenses, plus $619,000 in savings and a $350,000 Toronto home.
They have obviously managed their finances well to achieve such a high level of savings. Only part of the money came from a recent inheritance, and the sale of a second property. More significantly, they have not spent lavishly on their family home. They raised only one child and delayed drawing on savings.
Now they wonder how fast to spend their savings, yet not run out.
Cynthia Kett of Stewart & Kett Financial Advisors Inc. proposes a simple and conservative rule of thumb that any of us could use to pace the use of our savings to last a lifetime.
First she took into account the tax Carl will owe as he gradually draws down the $224,000 now in his registered retirement savings plan (RRSP). She deducted 20 per cent for tax, the rate most retired Ontario couples will pay if their taxable income is evenly split and totals no more than $79,500 a year.
Then Kett divided $573,000, her estimate of their net savings, by 25 – the number of years between age 70 and 95. This will limit the risk of running out of money, as only about an eighth of Ontario residents who reach age 70 are expected to live to age 95. (An eighth of men could reach 94, and an eighth of women 97.)
(Note: A life-expectancy calculator is available on the website lifeinsurancecanada.com. It provides the age that half of those of a certain age will attain. Then the expected lifespan of the half who survive can be tested, and so on.)
By Kett’s formula, Carl and Donna could comfortably spend an additional $22,200 from savings and investment income the first year. They could increase spending each following year in line with the rise of consumer prices, just like a government pension plan.
Only two possible hitches could arise. They could live longer than about 87 per cent of those their age, or their investment returns could disappoint.
But Kett, who is both a Chartered Accountant and Certified Financial Planner, set a modest investment target – the same as the annual rate of price inflation, plus enough to cover the taxes on the investment income.
So, if inflation were to average 3 per cent over the next 25 years, Carl and Donna’s savings would need to earn 3.75 per cent a year.
If inflation were to average about 2 per cent, which is more than during the past 20 years, they would have to earn 2.5 per cent on investments.
That lower inflation amount is about all that a retail investors can now obtain investing directly in long-term Government of Canada bonds. So Kett would encourage Carl and Donna to continue including corporate shares in their portfolios.
Kett cautions that some of the $22,200 in 2013 dollars that Carl and Donna could withdraw each year would be needed to offset a decline in the purchasing power of Carl’s $18,000 company pension.
Unlike the $25,600 of income the couple receives from Old Age Security and Canada Pension Plan pensions, his company pension amount is fixed for life with no promise of annual adjustments.
In a world of 2 per cent inflation, a 70-year old retiree with a fixed pension would need an RRSP equal to about four times their annual pension and an annual investment return of 2.5 per cent to compensate for the loss of purchasing power over a 25-year period.
So Carl could either dedicate some of his RRSP to supplement his pension, or the couple could accept a gradual decline in purchasing power over the years.
It will be up to Carl and Donna to decide whether to actually spend as much as the limit revealed by Kett’s suggested formula.
They might wish to leave more than the value of their home to their heirs. They might wish to plan for major expenses such a home renovation, car purchases or the cost of help in the event of a disabling disease or injury.
They might also wish to save some capital in case Carl were to die before Donna, since she would lose his OAS pension, some of his CPP pension, and $6,000 of his company pension, Kett points out.
She recommends that Carl convert his RRSP to a registered retirement income fund (RRIF) before the end of the year he will turn 71, rather than purchase a life annuity from a life insurer.
“That will give them the maximum flexibility from a cash flow perspective,” she points out. The savings inside the RRIF could be transferred tax-free to Donna if Carl were to die, or to heirs if they both were to die.
“I wouldn’t recommend an annuity because interest rates are very low right now…(it) will generate relatively modest retirement income...(and) also the annual amount cannot be changed after the fact.”
Kett noted that Donna plans to use part of her inheritance to pay for their trip. She suggested that Carl repay her from his non-registered savings, and that Donna invest the money as she will pay less tax on investment earnings.
They should also make maximum use of the right to split income from Carl’s company pension and, in future, the income from his RRIF withdrawals.
The client
Carl and Donna, 70
Their situation
The retirees have nearly enough government pensions to pay their basic expenses, plus Carl’s $18,000 company pension, plus $619,000 in savings they would like to spend on some fun, but not so fast it could run out.
The strategy
Assume Carl will be able to use only 80 per cent of his $220,000 in registered retirement savings after tax, and after the adjustment, simply divide the total of all savings by 25 – the number of years that only about an eighth of 70-year-old Ontario residents might live. Limit annual withdrawals of capital and interest to a 25th of savings, or $22,200 per year.
Assets:
Home $350,000
Retirement savings $224,000
Non-registered investments $344,000
Tax-free savings $51,000
Three cars $20,000
Total: $989,000
Liabilities: $0
Annual income
Old Age Security $12,516
Canada Pension Plan $13,100
Company pension $18,000
Investment income $10,220
Total $53,826
Annual expenses
Property taxes $2,300
Shelter $9,666
Household operation $4,900
Medical $200
Transportation $5,900

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Retirement becoming a distant proposition for many Canadians, survey finds


Retirement becoming a distant proposition for many Canadians, survey finds

Five years after the financial crisis took a bite out of the Canadian economy and investment portfolios, 27 per cent of working Canadians expect to retire at age 66.
RYAN REMIORZ / THE CANADIAN PRESS sOURCE - TORONTO STARA survey by Sun Life Financial has found that a large number of Canadians now plan to work past the age of 65.
Five years after the financial crisis took a bite out of the Canadian economy and investment portfolios, 27 per cent of working Canadians say they expect to retire at age 66, according to a new survey from Sun Life Financial.
That’s down sharply from 2008, when 51 per cent thought they would be ready for their golden years at that point.
Almost one-third expect to work part-time at age 66, and 26 per cent expect to be working full-time, the annual survey found. The remaining 15 per cent aren’t sure.
“That’s really something to reflect on. You have three-quarters of the population thinking about the very real possibility of working past what we’ve always through was the traditional retirement age,” Kevin Dougherty, president of Sun Life Financial Canada, said in an interview.
“The economic crisis has had a very large impact on people’s retirement savings and financial security.”
Nearly two-thirds of those surveyed said that they expect they will need to work past age 66, while the remaining third said they will want to work.
And low interest rates are making it difficult to save at a time when people are living longer. “The good news is that we’re all living a lot longer,” Dougherty said. “As that resonates with people, they’re realizing that at age 65, you need to think about, on average, living another 20 years.”
Over one-third of those surveyed said that there is a serious risk of outliving their retirement savings.
Growing household debt levels are also at play, Dougherty said.
“The crisis has meant that people didn’t pay off debt as quickly as they hoped. As well, for some people they’ve had to borrow to get through some of the challenges in the last few years,” he said.
The survey also found that Canadians have a poor understanding of how much they will need to save. They think they will need an average income of $46,000 a year in retirement, but only aim to have about $385,000 in retirement savings, excluding their home and other property.
In reality, it would take about twice that amount of savings to guarantee that level of income, Dougherty said.
Perceptions are also changing as Baby Boomers get closer to retirement, Dougherty said.
“When retirement was 10 or 15 years away, it was harder to imagine the nature of the challenge but this is reality setting in.”
The online survey of approximately 3,000 working Canadians ages 30 to 65 was conducted between Nov. 29 and Dec. 6 by Ipsos Reid on behalf of Sun Life Financial.

Monday, February 4, 2013

RRSP baby steps: The $12.50 solution


RRSP baby steps: The $12.50 solution

Over half of Canadians aged 18 to 34 still don’t have an RRSP. Here's an easy way to get going. 
RRSPs: Start early and you only need a little.

You hear it from financial experts all the time – start saving for your future while you’re young. But when you’re young, you don’t have a lot of disposable income to play with. And there’s always an excuse – I’ll contribute when I get my next raise, after I pay off my student loans, or when I get a better job! 

While many of us hold an RRSP account, according to RBC,over half of Canadians aged 18 to 34 still don’t. And as the life expectancy for Canadians grow, we might have to save a lot more in order to have enough money for retirement. 

If you’re someone who hasn’t opened up an RRSP yet, here are four basic things you need to know about opening up your own account. 

1. Set a retirement goal 
It’s not that fun thinking ahead 30 or 40 years from now, but to make your RRSPs work, you will need to star thinking about what kind of retirement lifestyle you want to live. Do you want to spend your time traveling? Will you be happy living in a condo or cottage – or will you want a large house? Chances are, your priorities and your desired retirement lifestyle will change as you get older, but having a rough idea in place now will give you a starting point for future planning decisions. 

2. Take baby steps 
You don’t have to start by saving hundreds of dollars from every pay cheque. Find a number that works for you – even if it’s only $25 bi-weekly – and have it automatically deducted from your bank account as soon as you get paid. An amount that small will do nothing to disrupt your lifestyle. And once you see that money start to accumulate in your account, you might be inspired to start saving a little more from every pay cheque. 

The key is to keep investing regularly into your account. Establishing a pattern of savings now while you’re young, will ensure that saving money becomes a force of habit when you’re older. Whether you decide on bi-weekly contributions, or a lump-sum payment once a year – figure out which strategy works best for your lifestyle, and stick to it. 

3. You can manage everything online 
The emergence of online banking makes it simple to open and contribute to an RRSP account. If you feel comfortable doing it yourself, you can go to your bank’s website, fill out some personal information, and follow the instructions to open up an account yourself. But don’t worry – if the thought of opening up an RRSP by yourself is too intimidating for you, just make an appointment at your bank’s local branch. Someone there will be able to help you open up an account, and show you how to access your investments online. 

4. RRSP vs. TFSA 
There are so many pros and cons about whether 20-somethings should use RRSPs or TFSAs. Many young people choose the TFSA because of its flexibility. You can withdraw the money you’ve contributed at any time, penalty-free. Whereas with an RRSP, you can only withdraw money penalty-free by using the First Time Home Buyer’s Plan (HBP) or the Life Long Learning Plan (LLP).  

When you contribute to your RRSP, you might get money back when you do your taxes. What happens is, when you do your taxes, the government reduces your income by the amount that you’ve contributed. For example, if you made $15,000 in 2011 and put $3,000 into your RRSP account, according to the government, you’ve only made $12,000. They will then give you back the taxes you paid on that $3,000 in income. 

Do you currently contribute to an RRSP? 



Krystal Yee lives in Vancouver and blogs at Give Me Back My Five Bucks. You can reach her on Twitter (@krystalatwork), or by e-mail at krystalatwork@gmail.com

Monday, May 14, 2012

Four common types of RRSPs


Four common types of RRSPs

With any of these plans, you have the option of paying for the help of a professional adviser. An adviser can help guide you to choose investments that are right for you.
  1. A basic RRSP
    • For people who want a simple account in their own name
    • Available at a bank or other financial institution
    • Offers a smaller range of investment choices, with some advice from the staff
    • You may or may not pay fees for the plan; investment costs are extra and may include commissions and other charges.
  2. A self-directed RRSP
    • For people who feel they know enough to choose their own investments
    • Available at a brokerage firm
    • Offers a wider range of investment choices, without advice
    • You pay the costs of the plan and investment costs.
    • Learn more about self-directed RRSPs.
  3. A group RRSP at work
    • For people who have this option at their workplace
    • Each member of the group has their own RRSP, but they are all looked after by the same life insurance company, bank or mutual fund company
    • May offer a range of investment choices
    • The money you put into the plan is often taken out of your pay; your employer may add to your savings
    • Your employer pays the costs of the plan; you pay investment costs.

    Note that if your employer does pay into your RRSP account, there may be policies that make it hard for you to take the money out before you retire. Before deciding to join a Group RRSP, find out how it works, what you can invest in, and what fees you may have to pay. Also, find out how much your employer will put in, and ask about any rules for when and how you can get your money from the plan.

    Tip: When you get a new job, it’s a good idea to check your employee benefits and see if you can join a group RRSP plan.
  4. Spousal or partner RRSP
    • For people who want to contribute money to their spouse or partner’s RRSP to balance their incomes and reduce taxes at retirement
    • The person who contributes gets the tax break
    • To qualify you must have lived together as a couple for at least 12 months, have a child together by birth or adoption, or share custody and support of your partner’s children from a previous  relationship.
Note that the money you contribute to a spousal RRSP belongs to your spouse or partner. If a couple breaks up, family law generally requires spouses to divide assets equally. This is not the case for common-law partners. You might consider drafting a joint agreement to cover this.

Tip: If for some reason you and your spouse need some of your RRSP money before you retire, you may have to pay tax when you take the money out. Having a spousal RRSP gives you the option of taking the money from the RRSP that is in the name of the lower-earning spouse. That way, you will have a lower tax bill.

Remember: A basic RRSP is not the only choice.

Make sure you choose the kind of plan that fits your personal situation and the way you like to invest your savings.

Friday, November 25, 2011

RRSP vs. Tax-free savings Which is best?


RRSP vs. Tax-free savings Which is best?

In an excerpt from The Wealthy Barber Returns author David Chilton looks at which tax-sheltered vehicle is best- your RRSP or tax-free savings account.

In this excerpt from The Wealthy Barber Returns, called the Battle of the Abbreviations, author David Chilton looks at the pros and cons of saving in your RRSP or a tax-free savings account.
Remember when life was simple? You needed to save and invest for retirement, so you opened an RRSP and contributed as much as you could each year.
Sure, the saving part was tough. And, of course, investing always had its challenges. But at least we all knew that an RRSP was the way to go.
Everybody said so. The woman on TV. Your advisor. The Wealthy Barber guy. Even your know-nothin’ cousin.
Then in 2009, along came the TFSA — totally fantastic savings account (or tax-free savings account).
Hmm. Suddenly, a second option to house our retirement dollars. What to do?
Many counsel us to put the maximum allowable amount into both our RRSPs and our TFSAs. For big-income, childless people living rent-free in their parents’ basements, that’s unquestionably solid advice.
The rest of us are probably going to have to prioritize. We need to figure out which vehicle to focus on first.
When you make an RRSP contribution, you get to deduct that amount from your taxable income. The investments inside your RRSP grow free of tax while they stay in the plan. Down the road, however, when money is withdrawn directly from the RRSP or from the registered retirement income fund (RRIF) or annuity to which the RRSP has been converted, it will be taxable.
I’m alarmed by how many Canadians still don’t fully grasp that last point. Over and over again, I see net-worth statements where the full value of an individual’s RRSP is listed on the Assets side, but no corresponding eventual-tax-owing amount is recorded on the Liabilities side.
You may have a $110,000 RRSP but you also have a partner — the government — waiting patiently for its share. Annoying, but true.
In essence, a TFSA is the mirror image of an RRSP. You contribute after-tax dollars. In other words, you don’t get a deduction for your contribution. But once the money is in the plan, it not only grows free of tax, but also comes out free of tax. No tax ever! Fantastico!
If you don’t love TFSAs, sorry, you’re nuts. But that doesn’t necessarily mean you should love them more than RRSPs.
When the federal government introduced TFSAs, it created a chart similar to this one:
I’ve spent almost two full books trying to avoid number-laden charts, but this simple, little table is quite illuminating. It neatly shows how a TFSA contribution is made with after-tax dollars, while withdrawals are tax-free. And an RRSP contribution is made with pre-tax dollars, while withdrawals are taxable. Yes, I’ve already explained that, but I thought it best to repeat.
The chart also demonstrates that if your marginal tax rate at the time of the RRSP contribution is the same as at the time of the withdrawal, TFSAs and RRSPs work out equally well.
Even the numerically challenged can understand that if the marginal tax rate is lower at the time of withdrawal than at the time of contribution, the RRSP will win. Conversely, if the marginal tax rate is higher at the time of withdrawal than at the time of contribution, the TFSA will win.
Easy, right? You just need to guess your marginal tax rate at the time of potential withdrawal and base your decision on that.
I’m so disappointed that it’s not that simple, darn it. I love simple. But sadly, the real world is more complicated than the chart world. Quite a bit more complicated.
In the last chapter, we saw that many of us, if not most of us, contribute to RRSPs with after-tax savings and then spend the refund. I hope the previous chapter changes that, but for right now, that’s the way it is. Heck, having some fun with our refund cheque is like playing this year’s first golf game or gardening on May 24th — it’s an annual Canadian tradition. A rite of spring.
Let’s look at a new chart that reflects that reality:
Holy smokes, the TFSA is kickin’ butt!
“That’s not fair,” you might argue. “You forgot to include the $400 tax refund that the RRSP contribution generates!”
No, I didn’t. It’s a chair now. Or half an iPad. Or a flight to Vegas.
And that’s fine. I’m not saying it was squandered — chairs are important, especially when you’re sitting. But it does mean the $400 won’t help your retirement and, therefore, in this scenario, from a financial-planning perspective, the TFSA is a clear winner.
Even when we assume you’ll follow the first chart’s lead and contribute to an RRSP the pre-tax equivalent of the TFSA contribution ($1,000 to $600), the comparison is still trickier than it first seemed.
Why?
When you withdraw money from your RRSP or RRIF (or receive an income from an annuity to which your RRSP was converted), not only do you have to pay taxes on it, but your increased income could also lead to higher clawbacks of your Old Age Security pension, Guaranteed Income Supplement and other means-tested government benefits.
Yikes, the math here is more complex than the RRSP versus RESP debate. Way more. I don’t even drink and I want a beer.
And talk about assumptions! Oh my. Go ahead: Take your best guess at what your taxable income will be 10, 20 and 30 years down the road. What about future tax rates? Will clawback rules be altered? In retirement, will you be able to income split with your spouse or will your spouse already have split with some of your income?
Wow. Maybe I should make that beer a scotch.
I’ve checked out a dozen analyses on the Internet and all that did was reinforce how challenging this comparison is. For example, very few factored in the effect an RRSP contribution can make on the amount of the Canada Child Tax Benefit (CCTB) parents receive. Also, almost all of the researchers assumed every dollar withdrawn from an RRSP or RRIF will be taxed at the marginal tax rate. Think about that — it’s not always the case. If I have $10,000 in government-pension income and receive a RRIF payment of $53,000, it’s not all going to be taxed at the marginal rate. In some cases, it would be more appropriate to use the average rate of tax on the withdrawal in the calculations.
That’s not nitpicky — points like the last one can’t be ignored. They’re vital parts of the evaluation. Unfortunately.
Wake up! I’m almost done.
Based on the various assumption sets I used, the TFSA won a surprising percentage of the time (though usually not by a wide margin). In fact, for most low-income earners, it was the victor under the majority of scenarios.
That said, I frankly have no idea which way you should go. At the risk of being branded The Wishy-Washy Barber, I think it would be irresponsible to give a definitive “do this.” Sit down with your advisor — he or she will at least have the advantage of being able to customize the assumptions to your situation. Plus, I’m sure there will soon be software or an app developed to help you figure this out. Try to curb your enthusiasm.
My final thought here is important (no, really!). TFSAs are very flexible. You can take money out of one at any time and then put it back in future years. That’s being trumpeted as a huge positive by many financial writers, but it scares the heck out of me.
I’m worried that many Canadians who are using TFSAs as retirement-savings vehicles are going to have trouble avoiding the temptation to raid their plans. Many will rationalize, “I’ll just dip in now to help pay for our trip, but I’ll replace it next year.” Will they? It’s tough enough to save the new contributions each year. Also setting aside the replacement money? Colour me skeptical. The reason I always sound so distrustful of people’s fiscal discipline is that after decades of studying financial plans, I am always distrustful of people’s fiscal discipline. And even if I’m proven wrong and the money is recontributed, what about the sacrificed growth while the money was out of the TFSA? Gone forever.
Reminders: (1) If you go the RRSP route, don’t spend your refund; (2) If you go the TFSA route, don’t spend your TFSA; (3) Whatever route you go, save more!
Excerpted from The Wealthy Barber Returns: Significantly Older and Marginally Wiser, Dave Chilton Offers His Unique Perspectives on the World of Money By David Chilton. Copyright © 2011 by David Barr Chilton.